OrgDecoded .in
← All essays
NOVEMBER 2026 · 6 MIN READ · BY ORGDECODED

The Door Before the Resume

Why a college name can decide who gets seen, what the research says is really going on, and whether it will ever change.

Picture a recruiter with a pile of resumes and a few seconds for each. Two land on top of one another. One is from a campus everybody has heard of, with decent but unremarkable grades. The other is from a good college that hardly anyone outside its own city knows, and the candidate is a gold medalist.

Nobody has to say which one gets the call. Everybody in the room already knows.

I've heard some version of that story in more than one workplace, usually told quietly, half as a joke. The joke always hides the same question: is it actually true, and if it is, is it fair?

So I went looking for evidence. What I found was messier than the rumour.

First, the Facts (They Don't All Point the Same Way)

The sharpest evidence for the rumour is a study of about 15,000 engineering graduates by the assessment company Aspiring Minds. Researchers held test scores and academic percentages equal and compared outcomes by college tier. A tier-3 graduate had 24% lower odds of getting a job and earned roughly Rs 66,000 a year less than an equally capable tier-1 graduate. A tier-2 graduate had 12% lower odds. The reason was almost boring: companies visit only certain campuses, and resumes from unknown colleges often never reach the shortlist.

Same ability. Different outcome. Decided by a name.

Two caveats before we get angry. That data is from the 2013 graduating batch, and the company behind it sells skills assessments, which are exactly what would make college names matter less. Treat it as a strong signal, not a verdict.

A separate study by economist Sheetal Sekhri adds a twist. Graduates of elite public colleges in India earned higher salaries even though their exit test scores were no different from students who just missed the admission cutoff. The brand paid. The extra learning didn't show up.

Now the complication. A 2024 experiment sent nearly 17,000 fictional resumes to over 1,400 job postings for recent engineering graduates at small and medium firms. A mid-tier college versus an unranked one made almost no difference to callbacks.

So who's right? Possibly both. My reading is that the bias lives less at the recruiter's desk and more at the gate: which campuses companies visit, and whose resumes are in the pile at all. The Aspiring Minds report found that more than 70% of employable engineers studied outside the top 100 colleges. They weren't invisible because they lacked skill. They were invisible because nobody was looking.

To be fair to the shortcut, top-100 colleges did show employability rates two to four times higher than the rest. A good name isn't random. It's a blunt instrument.

Why Does the Shortcut Survive?

Economists call it signalling. When a recruiter can't see ability, they read cheap signals instead, and a college name is the cheapest one around. It also carries real information, since getting into a top campus usually means clearing a brutal entrance exam. Add the sheer volume of applications, and a recruiter drowning in resumes reaches for whatever is fastest.

The trouble is what a blunt instrument does at the edges. The gold medalist lives at the edge.

There's a quieter cost too, and this is the psychology student in me talking. In that same study, tier-3 students expected to earn about Rs 70,000 less in their first job than tier-1 students, and were less interested in large companies. The report's own explanation is that they aim for what feels reachable. The system doesn't just filter people. It teaches them what to expect.

Is It Unfair? My Take

At the margins, yes. A candidate who can do the job and never gets the chance to show it is a loss for everyone, including the company that never met them.

But I don't think the answer is blaming recruiters, or taking shots at top-college graduates, who cleared real filters to get there. Recruiters are doing the rational thing with the signals they have. The problem is that a name is often the only signal on the page.

So the fix, in my view, is to give them a better one, and that has three parts. Put a short skill check or work sample ahead of the shortlist for everyone, so ability gets seen before the logo does. Widen the gate with off-campus and virtual drives, so more colleges are in the pile to begin with. And keep screening structured: the same criteria and scoring for every candidate.

This is where HR earns its keep. Not by judging the name, but by redesigning the gate so a name isn't the only key that opens it.

Will It Ever Change?

There are signs. Deloitte India's 2026 Campus Workforce Trends report, covering 257 organisations and 505 campuses, finds hiring moving toward skills-based assessments and targeted shortlisting. But it also says degree and institute reputation still influence campus hiring and pay, with skills adding a new layer rather than replacing the old one. And a HirePro report on college hiring in 2026 points to a perception gap: 96% of colleges believe employers have embraced skills-first hiring, while employers' own answers suggest the shift is still unfinished.

My honest read: the name won't disappear. It will be joined by proof. For freshers, that means the safest bet isn't only getting into the right college. It's being able to show what you can do before anyone checks where you studied.

Whether that's real progress or just a more complicated hierarchy, I genuinely don't know.

So I'd love to ask the people who've done the shortlisting: in those first few seconds, what do you actually look at? And what would an unknown college's gold medalist have to show you to get the same call?


Sources: Aspiring Minds, National Employability Report: Engineers 2014; Sheetal Sekhri, "Prestige Matters," American Economic Journal: Applied Economics (2020); Batheja, Hirshleifer & Kaur, "Does Signaling College-Level Human Capital Matter?" (CEGA, 2024); Deloitte India, Campus Workforce Trends 2026; HirePro, State of College Hiring in India 2026.

Enjoyed this? Tell me if you've seen it too — share your thoughts on LinkedIn and tag me, or pass it to someone who does the shortlisting. New essays every other week.